No, NVRs are not "A Single Point of Failure"

Recently, a competitor started claiming that NVRs are a "single point of failure." In a proper set up, NVRs are not a "single point of failure" but your building's power is. Let's talk about reducing risk and how the company making this claim actually increases your risk.

surveillance industry shortchange

What's the claim?

There's a security camera company that has been claiming that NVRs are a "single point of failure," and that they are being replaced by on-board camera storage.

Who is Making the Claim

This claim is part of a section of their sales pitch which, depending on the salesman, implies or directly states, that only their equipment is secure. This sales pitch claims that the use of NVRs is somehow "outdated." This sales presentation spreads misinformation about the way that a NVR works.

Our NVRs Don't Have a Single Point of Failure

With a SCW system you can easily get 9 different types of copies of the video if you want:

 on-board camera storage
 storage on the NVR
 a hot swap NVR (a backup NVR in a different on-site location)
 FTP backup of events with our Snapshot feature
 RAID on the NVR
 a backup via eSata through the NVR
 a NAS backup through the NVR
 a backup on your monitoring station through our CMS
 a backup in the cloud by either utilizing our Cirrus service or several other services that our cameras are compatible.

It's all Projection

Their sales presentation often presents the NVR as the "single point of failure." Let's talk about when security systems fail.

1. Each Camera is a "Single Point of Failure" in Their System

This company's solution only sends low resolution thumbnails to the cloud, which means that if the camera is vandalized, there's no central repository for meaningful HD video data. That means that each camera is a single point of failure, in and of itself.

2. The Risks are Opposite What They Claim.

Cameras are vandalized frequently; NVRs are almost never vandalized. Every time one of their cameras is hit with a baseball bat or stolen, there will be data loss. This will be a common occurrence because vandalism is going to be your most frequent security incident.

Almost all properties have multiple layers of security.

To disable a properly set up NVR based system, you would have to enter the building, disable the alarm system, break the maglock or hack the access control system, know where the NVR and the Hot Swap NVRs are located, disconnect and steal the NVR, and then disconnect and steal all of the backups, many of which will not be common knowledge. If you were subscribed to our Cirrus cloud based backup (or any other cloud service), they would also have to find the data center, break into that and destroy that evidence. This is nearly impossibly infrequent security incident.

A camera mounted outside of your property that houses the ONLY surveillance data for that device is outside of all your additional layers of security. This is paramount to putting your customer data on a sever outside your property.

you wouldn't put your server outside

3. Their Solution Increases Catastrophic Risks

Your real "single point of failure" security risk is having your power cut.

When using a NVR, you typically cable all your cameras to a central location where the POE switches are located. This is easy to integrate with a battery backup system, since all your camera connections are in one place. One of their claims is that you can just plug the camera into your network. This sounds like a distributed system, but this is actually clumsy, confusing and overly complicated. The number of POE switches and battery backups this would require would be cost prohibitive and difficult to maintain.

The logical response, even with their system, would be to centralize your camera POE power connections so that they are all on battery backups. If someone gained access to that area, they could cut all the cables, just like the way that if someone gained access to your NVR, they could steal the NVR.

In short, Their Proposed Solution Creates Multiple Points of Failure.


  1. The 4MP Imperial Series (4MP is 2 x 1080P) - 100 Channel HD Customizable Security Camera System




    Cameras


    4MP @ 25 FPS: 2560 x 1440

    80.8° or 101° options
    IP67 Weatherproof
    Infrared night vision up to 100 FT
    -31°F to 140 °F temp rated
    True Wide Dynamic Range (120dB)



    4MP vs 4K.


    Software


    VCA: Motion Detection, Line Crossing, Face Detection, Intrusion Detection, People Counting, Vandalism Detection
    Video Content Analytics (VCA) Search
    VCA Event based Email Alerts
    Remote Footage Download
    1 Click Firmware Update

    Learn when you would use VCA


    Remote Viewing


    Smartphone Apps
    Tablet Apps
    Windows Apps
    Mac Viewing Apps
    Internet Explorer Viewing

    How Patent Wars have changed Browser Support


    Hardware


    Cat5e (RJ45) Ethernet to Network
    Standard 3-Prong Wall Plug
    POE Switches for flexibility in cable runs
    VGA Monitor Out
    4K HDMI Out for TVs/Monitors
    Footage Download via USB

    Learn about automatic backup footage options



  2. The 4MP Motorized Imperial Series - 100 Channel HD Customizable Security Camera System




    Cameras


    4MP @ 25 FPS: 2560 x 1440

    Motorized Varifocal: 2.8 - 12mm
    91° - 27° of coverage
    IP67 Weatherproof
    Infrared night vision up to 100 FT
    -31°F to 140 °F temp rated
    True Wide Dynamic Range (120dB)



    4MP vs 4K.


    Software


    VCA: Motion Detection, Line Crossing, Face Detection, Intrusion Detection, People Counting, Vandalism Detection
    Video Content Analytics (VCA) Search
    VCA Event based Email Alerts
    Remote Footage Download
    1 Click Firmware Update

    Learn when you would use VCA


    Remote Viewing


    Smartphone Apps
    Tablet Apps
    Windows Apps
    Mac Viewing Apps
    Internet Explorer Viewing

    How Patent Wars have changed Browser Support


    Hardware


    Cat5e (RJ45) Ethernet to Network
    Standard 3-Prong Wall Plug
    POE Switches for flexibility in cable runs
    VGA Monitor Out
    4K HDMI Out for TVs/Monitors
    Footage Download via USB

    Learn about automatic backup footage options



  3. The 4K Motorized Imperial Series - 100 Channel HD Customizable Security Camera System




    Cameras


    4K (8MP) UHD @ 30 FPS: 3840 x 2160

    Motorized Varifocal: 2.8 - 12mm
    91° - 27° of coverage
    IP67 Weatherproof
    Infrared night vision up to 325 or 100 FT
    P-Iris Lens or IK10 impact rating
    Extreme Cold Temperature rated from -40°F to 140 °F
    True Wide Dynamic Range (120dB)



    4MP vs 4K.


    Software


    VCA: Motion Detection, Line Crossing, Face Detection, Intrusion Detection, People Counting, Vandalism Detection
    Video Content Analytics (VCA) Search
    VCA Event based Email Alerts
    Remote Footage Download
    1 Click Firmware Update

    Learn when you would use VCA


    Remote Viewing


    Smartphone Apps
    Tablet Apps
    Windows Apps
    Mac Viewing Apps
    Internet Explorer Viewing

    How Patent Wars have changed Browser Support


    Hardware


    Cat5e (RJ45) Ethernet to Network
    Standard 3-Prong Wall Plug
    POE Switches for flexibility in cable runs
    VGA Monitor Out
    4K HDMI Out for TVs/Monitors
    Footage Download via USB

    Learn about automatic backup footage options



  4. The 4K Imperial Series - 100 Channel HD Customizable Security Camera System



    100 Camera 4K Imperial Series

    From: $35,576.99


    Cameras


    4K (8MP) UHD @ 15 FPS: 3840 x 2160

    92° or 118° options
    IP67 Weatherproof
    Infrared night vision up to 100 FT
    -31°F to 140 °F temp rated

    4MP vs 4K.


    Software


    VCA: Motion Detection, Line Crossing, Face Detection, Intrusion Detection, People Counting, Vandalism Detection
    Video Content Analytics (VCA) Search
    VCA Event based Email Alerts
    Remote Footage Download
    1 Click Firmware Update

    Learn when you would use VCA


    Remote Viewing


    Smartphone Apps
    Tablet Apps
    Windows Apps
    Mac Viewing Apps
    Internet Explorer Viewing

    How Patent Wars have changed Browser Support


    Hardware


    Cat5e (RJ45) Ethernet to Network
    Standard 3-Prong Wall Plug
    POE Switches for flexibility in cable runs
    VGA Monitor Out
    4K HDMI Out for TVs/Monitors
    Footage Download via USB

    Learn about automatic backup footage options